handing-back-the-keys-ending-a-commercial-lease-blog-FEATURED-IMAGE

By Hasin Tariq Amin, Associate Solicitor, Commercial Property Dispute Resolution, WHN Solicitors. Recognised by the Legal 500 as a recommended lawyer.

Most commercial leases do not simply stop. A lease runs for its term, and ending a commercial lease properly takes more than deciding you no longer need the premises.

Signed, Sealed and Leased is a four-part video series from WHN’s Commercial Property Dispute Resolution team, covering the life of a commercial lease from start to finish. This article is the written companion to the third video, which you can watch below.

Can You Get out of a Commercial Lease by Walking Away?

No. Vacating the premises and handing back the keys does not end a commercial lease. The rent and every other obligation in the lease carry on until it is brought to an end in one of the ways set out below, and a tenant who stops paying in the meantime is exposed to a claim for the arrears.

There is one exception though. If the landlord accepts the keys and then acts as though the lease has actually ended, the law may treat it as having been surrendered. Simply taking the keys is usually not enough, since a landlord may just be holding on to them temporarily. 

What tips it over is conduct only a landlord who has taken the property back would engage in, such as letting it to someone else or moving back in. But that decision rests with the landlord alone, not the person renting, so it is not something a tenant can plan around.

 

How Can a Commercial Lease be Brought to an End?

A commercial lease ends in one of four ways:

  • A break clause, if the lease contains one, allowing the landlord or tenant to end it early by serving the correct notice.
  • Expiry at the end of the term, which for a lease protected by the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 also requires the correct statutory notice.
  • A surrender, where landlord and tenant agree to end the lease early.
  • Forfeiture, where the landlord ends the lease because the tenant is in breach.

Which of these is open to you comes down to two questions. The first is where you are in the term: if the lease still has time to run, a break clause is the only way to end it early without the landlord’s agreement, and without one you need the landlord to agree to a surrender. 

The second is whether the lease is protected by the 1954 Act or contracted out of it, which decides what happens at expiry. Forfeiture follows its own rules and is covered in part four.

How Do You Know if Your Lease is Protected?

To determine whether your lease is protected or not, check the lease itself as well as the paperwork from when it was originally granted. A contracted-out lease will normally state that sections 24 to 28 of the 1954 Act are excluded, and the tenant should have been served a warning notice prior to entering into the lease and then signed a declaration accepting it. 

If that procedure was not followed correctly, the exclusion fails and the lease is protected, whatever the lease itself says. The steps have to happen in the right order and before the tenant is committed to the lease: the landlord serves the warning notice, the tenant signs a declaration (a statutory declaration before a solicitor if the notice was served less than 14 days before signing), and the lease refers to both. 

A notice served after the lease was signed, a missing declaration, or a lease that doesn’t reference them can all leave the tenant with security of tenure that neither side intended. For a landlord, that means the property does not come back at expiry. For a tenant, it can mean renewal rights they didn’t even know they had.

Can You Use a Break Clause to End Your Lease Early?

Only if your lease has one, the right to use it is yours, and you meet every condition attached to it by the break date. A break clause lets the landlord, the tenant or both end the lease early by serving notice, and most are conditional on things such as having the rent paid up to date and giving vacant possession.

Each condition has to be fulfilled exactly, and notice served a day late is not valid notice. If any condition is not met, the lease continues as it was, with every obligation in it, through to the contractual expiry date. For a tenant who has already committed to new premises, that can mean paying rent on two properties for a significant period of time.

Our guide to break clauses in commercial leases goes through the conditions that most often defeat a break, how to serve the notice, and what to agree about the break before you sign.

What Happens When a Commercial Lease Expires?

The process for when a commercial lease expires will depend entirely on whether the lease is protected by the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 or contracted out of it: 

If the lease is protected, it does not end on the expiry date. It continues until one side serves the correct notice under the 1954 Act, and the timing rules are strict:

  • A landlord serves a section 25 notice, either proposing terms for a new tenancy or stating that renewal is opposed and on which statutory grounds.
  • A tenant who does not vacate on the date stated within the lease is seen as occupying without any right to do so, and the landlord can commence possession proceedings against them as a result.
  • Both section 25 notices and section 26 requests must specify a date between six and twelve months after they are served.
  • A tenant who wants to leave serves a section 27 notice. Given at least three months before the contractual expiry date, it stops the lease continuing; if the tenant is already holding over, it ends the tenancy on at least three months’ notice.

If the lease is contracted out:

  • It ends automatically on the contractual expiry date, and no notice is needed from either side.
  • The tenant has no right to a new lease and must leave by that date.
  • A tenant who stays becomes a trespasser, covered in the next section.

What if a Contracted-out Tenant Holds Over After the Lease Expires?

If a contracted-out tenant were to remain in a premises after their lease has expired, they would become trespassers. When a lease has been contracted out, the tenant has no security of tenure and no longer possesses the right to remain after the contractual expiry date. 

A tenant who does not vacate on the date stated within the lease is seen as occupying without any right to do so, and the landlord can commence possession proceedings against them as a result.

Ultimately, a tenant holding over under a protected lease is considered still a tenant, with the lease continuing and their statutory rights intact. A contracted-out tenant who stays on is not, they have no right to be there, and no defence to a possession claim. On top of possession, the landlord can claim compensation for the period the tenant stayed, known as mesne profits, along with its legal costs.

There is one trap here for landlords. Accepting rent after the lease has expired can, depending on the circumstances, create a new tenancy, and unless it is documented properly, that new tenancy may carry the security of tenure the original lease excluded.

What is a Surrender, and When Does it Make Sense?

A surrender is an agreement between a landlord and tenant to end a lease early. This is the recommended route to consider when no break right is available, and expiry is too far off to be viable.

Most cases of surrenders I see are negotiated and recorded in a deed, and they often involve payment of a premium by the tenant to compensate for the landlord being asked to give up their rental income stream.

It is recommended to always take professional advice prior to agreeing anything, and before doing anything that could look like agreement. A surrender can also happen by operation of law, with no deed and nothing in writing, where both sides behave in a way that is inconsistent with the lease continuing. The tenant moves out and hands back the keys; the landlord re-lets the premises or takes them back into use. At that point the lease has ended, whether or not either side meant it to.

That outcome suits nobody. The tenant has left with nothing in writing releasing them from dilapidations or confirming what happens to the deposit. The landlord may have given up the right to future rent without negotiating anything in return. At this point the dispute becomes about whether a surrender happened at all, and on what date.

When a surrender occurs, what happens to the rent deposit is usually determined as part of the negotiations. It is usually held under a separate rent deposit deed, and ending the lease does not trigger its return automatically. Depending on the deed, the landlord often keeps all or part of it until arrears are paid, the final service charge has been reconciled, and any dilapidations claim is settled. The deed of surrender should say how much comes back, when this happens, and what can be deducted, so there is nothing left to argue about later.

A surrender can also affect people other than the landlord and tenant. If you have sublet part of the premises, the surrender does not end your subtenant’s rights; they generally become the landlord’s direct tenant instead, which is why landlords often insist that subleases are ended before agreeing a surrender. If someone guaranteed your lease, the surrender releases them from obligations going forward, but they remain liable for anything already owed on the surrender date.

Can you Transfer a Lease Instead of Ending It?

Where ending the lease is not realistic, it may be possible to pass it on instead. Assignment transfers the lease to a new tenant for the rest of the term. Underletting keeps you as the tenant but puts someone else in all, or part, of the space. Both usually require the landlord’s consent.

While neither assignment nor underletting will necessarily cut your ties from the property, both can take the premises off your hands day to day and bring in income against the rent. This is often enough when the priority is to stop paying for space you no longer use.

The ties that remain are worth understanding before you commit though: On assignment, the landlord will often require an authorised guarantee agreement, under which you guarantee that the incoming tenant pays the rent and complies with the lease; if they default, the landlord can come back to you. With an underlet, you remain the tenant and fully liable to the landlord, whatever your undertenant does.

What Does a Tenant Owe When a Lease Ends?

Rent and other sums run to the termination date, and the repairing obligations fall due at the end. Most leases require the property to be handed back in the condition the covenants specify, and many also require alterations to be reinstated. The dilapidations claim that follows is often the largest single cost of exiting a lease.

The recommendation is to deal with this well before you leave. A survey twelve months out tells you what your liability looks like while there is still time to do the work yourself, negotiate the scope with the landlord, or budget for a settlement.

What Happens Next?

Part four of Signed, Sealed, and Leased looks at forfeiture: the landlord’s right to bring a lease to an end because the tenant is in breach, how it is exercised, and what a tenant can do about it.

Get Advice Before You Serve Notice

The mistakes that cost most in lease terminations are procedural. A break condition missed, the wrong notice served, a surrender agreed without anyone intending it. They are all avoidable, and almost none of them can be fixed afterwards.

Hasin Tariq Amin is an Associate Solicitor at WHN Solicitors specialising in commercial property dispute resolution and landlord and tenant disputes. Recognised by the Legal 500 as a recommended lawyer, and with over eight years of post-qualification experience, he acts for landlords, tenants, developers and property owners on break notices, lease renewals, forfeiture, relief from forfeiture, dilapidations claims and possession proceedings.

To discuss ending a commercial lease, fill in our contact form, call 0161 761 8089, or email hasintariq.amin@whnsolicitors.co.uk.

Key resources